In terms of architectural style and real estate diversity, some “West of the Trail” neighborhoods are considered to be more prestigious than others, and Poinsettia Park Sarasota is certainly worthy of prestige. Located between Southside Elementary School and Siesta Drive, Poinsettia Park Sarasota is also known as the South Flowers District because of its street names and the flowery gardens that adorn many of the upscale properties.

Poinsettia Park is a historic Sarasota neighborhood that has always attracted spec and custom home building; as a result, you can find mansions built in the Spanish Colonial, Mediterranean, Tuscan, French country, and Modern architectural styles. Modest vintage homes dating back to the days before World War II have been carefully remodeled, but most of the properties have either been custom built in recent years or completely renovated to boost value.

Late 2024 pricing in Poinsettia Park starts under $700K for a three-bedroom Florida ranch completely renovated in the Sarasota Modern style; this is a home with two porches, granite fireplace, quartz countertops, and luxury laminate floors. The most spectacular property listed in 2024 is a $4.45 million French country estate with seven bedrooms and nine bathrooms plus a two-level living room with a separate dining room that can accommodate a meal for more than 20 guests; to complement its French country architecture, this chateau even features a large, walk-in wine cellar. Latest pricing at Poinsettia Park Sarasota will be found below if there is inventory.

By virtue of being adjacent to the Tamiami Trail, Poinsettia Park residents can walk to various shopping districts, including the Westfield Siesta Key plaza and its nearby CineBistro restaurant where you can enjoy meals at the same time you watch curated films. Siesta Drive connects to Bay Island and Siesta Key, which means that you only need to drive less than 10 minutes to enjoy a gorgeous beach with the whitest sand on Earth. The arts and culture district of Downtown Sarasota is about 15 minutes away.